Method note: I used exact vintage matching wherever possible. For many Del Dotto cave-only barrel designates, the exact cooperator/barrel label is not publicly visible in market listings, so I marked those as no exact comp unless a same-vintage, same-tier listing gave a defensible near comp. I did not substitute different vintages as hard market comps.
| Wine Description | Vintage | List Price | Market Price Found | Price Source | Critic Score | Verdict | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| St. Helena Mountain Vicard French Oak Block 3 | 2015 | $215.00 | No market data found | No exact-vintage market data found after web search / Wine-Searcher-visible snippets / Benchmark / WineBid / K&L / Vivino / CellarTracker / Del Dotto public pages | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | Likely Del Dotto direct/club/cave-only barrel-specific bottling; exact-vintage comp not verified. |
| Oakville EAST Darnajou French Oak Family Reserve | 2019 | $215.00 | $250.00 | Atlas Wine listing, Piazza Del Dotto Cabernet Sauvignon Oakville Estate Family Reserve 2019, likely same Oakville Family Reserve tier but barrel designation not shown | No exact critic score found | Fair | Secondary/retail comp supports $215 as below one listed retail comp, but exact Darnajou EAST barrel language was not confirmed on the listing. |
| Del Dotto Golden Lance Corona Warrior Cabernet Sauvignon | 2019 | $70.00 | $91.00 | Benchmark Wine Group, 2019 Del Dotto Cabernet Sauvignon Caves, same producer/vintage/value-tier cave Cabernet but not exact Golden Lance label | No exact critic score found | Fair | Exact Golden Lance / Corona Warrior vintage comp not found. Current Del Dotto club page shows Warrior Cabernets at $75 regular / $70 club for recent releases, matching Trevor's $70. |
| Oakville Family Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon | 2012 | $300.00 | No market data found | No exact-vintage market data found after web search / Wine-Searcher-visible snippets / Benchmark / WineBid / K&L / Vivino / CellarTracker / Del Dotto public pages | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | Likely Del Dotto direct/club/cave-only barrel-specific bottling; exact-vintage comp not verified. |
| St. Helena Mountain Vicard French Oak Block 3 | 2014 | $225.00 | $171.00 | Benchmark Wine Group, 2014 Del Dotto Cabernet Sauvignon Family Reserve St. Helena Mountain; WineBid exact title located for 2014 Vicard Block 3 but price not exposed | CT96 on Benchmark St. Helena Mountain 2014 listing | Fair | Not exact barrel comp from Benchmark, but same vintage, producer, vineyard/tier. Charge $225 is above $171 secondary comp but these barrel designates are DTC/exclusive. |
| Russian River Napa Valley Zinfandel | 2019 | $65.00 | No exact price found | Delectable product page; Del Dotto current club page lists 2022 Zinfandel NV $58 regular / $55 club, but not exact vintage | Delectable user ratings, no critic score | No Market Comp Available | No exact-vintage comp found; $65 is only modestly above current Del Dotto Zinfandel club pricing. |
| Del Dotto Weary Corona Warrior Cabernet Sauvignon | 2019 | $70.00 | $91.00 | Benchmark Wine Group, 2019 Del Dotto Cabernet Sauvignon Caves, same producer/vintage/value-tier cave Cabernet but not exact Weary label | No exact critic score found | Fair | Exact Weary / Corona Warrior vintage comp not found. Current Del Dotto club page shows Warrior Cabernets at $75 regular / $70 club for recent releases, matching Trevor's $70. |
| St. Helena Mountain Darnajou French Oak Family Reserve Block 3 | 2014 | $225.00 | $171.00 | Benchmark Wine Group, 2014 Del Dotto Cabernet Sauvignon Family Reserve St. Helena Mountain; WineBid found 2014 St. Helena Vicard Block 3 but not Darnajou | CT96 on Benchmark St. Helena Mountain 2014 listing | Fair | No Darnajou exact price; same-vintage St. Helena Family Reserve secondary comp is lower. |
| 7 Rows Cabernet Franc Family Reserve | 2018 | $125.00 | $78.00 | WineBid latest sale, 2018 Del Dotto Rutherford Estate 7 Rows Cabernet Franc, May 11 2025 | No critic score found | Overpriced | This is an exact or near-exact wine/vintage comp and is materially below the $125 charge. |
| Russian River Napa Valley Zinfandel | 2021 | $60.00 | No exact price found | No exact 2021 Russian River Valley Zinfandel comp found; unrelated 2021 Del Dotto Caves Red found at $78.99 | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | No exact-vintage comp found; $60 is close to current Del Dotto Zinfandel club pricing for 2022/2023 releases. |
| Oakville Darnajou French Oak Vitali & Majka Reserve South | 2018 | $215.00 | $328.99 | WinesAvailable, 2018 Del Dotto Piazza Oakville Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon, out of stock | No exact critic score found | Good Deal | Same vintage Oakville reserve tier but not same barrel designation; Trevor's $215 is materially lower. |
| Vineyard 887 Darnajou French Oak Vitali & Majka Reserve South | 2018 | $215.00 | $171.00 | Benchmark Wine Group, 2018 Del Dotto Cabernet Sauvignon Family Reserve Vineyard 887 | CT93 on Benchmark related Del Dotto listing group | Fair | Same vintage and Vineyard 887 Family Reserve, but barrel designation not exposed. |
| St. Helena Mountain Vicard Energie French Oak Block 2 Family Reserve | 2015 | $215.00 | No exact price found | WineBid page located for 2015 Del Dotto St. Helena Mountain Family Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon, but price not exposed | No exact critic score found | No Market Comp Available | No exact-vintage, exact-barrel price found. |
| St. Helena Mountain Family Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon | 2012 | $300.00 | $155.00 | WineBid latest sale, 2012 Del Dotto Connoisseurs' Series St. Helena Mountain Family Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon, July 18 2021 | Vivino aggregate 4.7 all vintages, not a critic score | Overpriced | Vintage and Family Reserve St. Helena Mountain match. Barrel designation not applicable in Trevor's line. |
| Piazza Del Dotto Cabernet Sauvignon Reserve | 2016 | $110.00 | $115.00 | Benchmark Wine Group, 2016 Del Dotto Cabernet Sauvignon Family Reserve Piazza del Dotto | CT90 on Benchmark listing | Fair | Trevor's $110 is slightly under Benchmark's $115. Exact reserve/family reserve naming is close and likely same tier. |
| Piazza Del Dotto Fort Ross Pinot Noir | 2019 | $95.00 | No market data found | No exact-vintage market data found after web search / Wine-Searcher-visible snippets / Benchmark / WineBid / K&L / Vivino / CellarTracker / Del Dotto public pages | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | Likely Del Dotto direct/club/cave-only barrel-specific bottling; exact-vintage comp not verified. |
| Oakville Darnajou French Oak Family Reserve South | 2014 | $215.00 | No market data found | No exact-vintage market data found after web search / Wine-Searcher-visible snippets / Benchmark / WineBid / K&L / Vivino / CellarTracker / Del Dotto public pages | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | Likely Del Dotto direct/club/cave-only barrel-specific bottling; exact-vintage comp not verified. |
| Piazza Del Dotto Chardonnay Sonoma Coast | 2022 | $85.00 | $84.00 | Benchmark Wine Group, 2021 Del Dotto Chardonnay Cinghiale Vineyard, closest producer Chardonnay comp; Del Dotto club page current Estate Chardonnay $85 regular / $75 club | CT91 for 2021 Benchmark listing | Fair | No exact 2022 Piazza Sonoma Coast Chardonnay comp found. Current Del Dotto Chardonnay pricing supports the $85 level. |
| St. Helena Mountain MGX Fouquet MT French Oak Family Reserve Block 2 | 2015 | $215.00 | No market data found | No exact-vintage market data found after web search / Wine-Searcher-visible snippets / Benchmark / WineBid / K&L / Vivino / CellarTracker / Del Dotto public pages | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | Likely Del Dotto direct/club/cave-only barrel-specific bottling; exact-vintage comp not verified. |
| Vineyard 887 Vicard Priviledge French Oak South | 2015 | $215.00 | No exact price found | WineBid found 2015 Vineyard 887 Centre Taransaud South, not Vicard Priviledge | No exact critic score found | No Market Comp Available | No exact barrel comp found. |
| Rutherford Estate Family Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon | 2017 | $195.00 | No exact price found | Delectable / Winedexer pages located but no exact price; related vintages only | Winedexer aggregate 4.6 all vintages, not a critic score | No Market Comp Available | No exact-vintage sale/retail comp verified. |
| Oakville Jupille French Oak Family Reserve South | 2014 | $215.00 | No market data found | No exact-vintage market data found after web search / Wine-Searcher-visible snippets / Benchmark / WineBid / K&L / Vivino / CellarTracker / Del Dotto public pages | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | Likely Del Dotto direct/club/cave-only barrel-specific bottling; exact-vintage comp not verified. |
| St. Helena Mountain Orion French Oak Family Reserve Block 3 | 2014 | $215.00 | $171.00 | Benchmark Wine Group, 2014 Del Dotto Cabernet Sauvignon Family Reserve St. Helena Mountain | CT96 on Benchmark St. Helena Mountain 2014 listing | Fair | No Orion exact price; same-vintage St. Helena Family Reserve secondary comp is lower. |
| St. Helena Mountain MGX French Oak Family Reserve Block 2 | 2012 | $250.00 | No market data found | No exact-vintage market data found after web search / Wine-Searcher-visible snippets / Benchmark / WineBid / K&L / Vivino / CellarTracker / Del Dotto public pages | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | Likely Del Dotto direct/club/cave-only barrel-specific bottling; exact-vintage comp not verified. |
| Oakville Vicard French Oak Reserve South | 2015 | $215.00 | No market data found | No exact-vintage market data found after web search / Wine-Searcher-visible snippets / Benchmark / WineBid / K&L / Vivino / CellarTracker / Del Dotto public pages | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | Likely Del Dotto direct/club/cave-only barrel-specific bottling; exact-vintage comp not verified. |
| Rutherford Estate Family Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon | 2014 | $195.00 | No exact price found | Delectable 2014 page located; Del Dotto library collection page located, no price exposed | Winedexer aggregate 4.6 all vintages, not a critic score | No Market Comp Available | No exact-vintage sale/retail comp verified. |
| Del Dotto Chaining of Corona Dragon Cabernet Sauvignon | 2019 | $70.00 | $91.00 | Benchmark Wine Group, 2019 Del Dotto Cabernet Sauvignon Caves, same producer/vintage/value-tier cave Cabernet but not exact Chaining label | No exact critic score found | Fair | Exact Chaining / Corona Dragon comp not found. Current Del Dotto club page shows Warrior/prophecy Cabernets at $75 regular / $70 club for recent releases, matching Trevor's $70. |
| Del Dotto Battle with Corona Dragon Cabernet | 2017 | $70.00 | No exact 2017 price found | Delectable page located; WineBid found 2018 Battle With The Corona Dragon, not same vintage | No exact critic score found | No Market Comp Available | No exact-vintage market comp found. Recent similar Del Dotto novelty Cabernets appear around $70 club pricing. |
| Piazza Oakville St. Emilion Fouquet French Oak South Cabernet Sauvignon | 2015 | $215.00 | No market data found | No exact-vintage market data found after web search / Wine-Searcher-visible snippets / Benchmark / WineBid / K&L / Vivino / CellarTracker / Del Dotto public pages | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | Likely Del Dotto direct/club/cave-only barrel-specific bottling; exact-vintage comp not verified. |
| Vineyard 887 Vicard Symetrie French Oak South | 2015 | $215.00 | No exact price found | WineBid found 2015 Vineyard 887 Centre Taransaud South, not Vicard Symetrie | No exact critic score found | No Market Comp Available | No exact barrel comp found. |
| Oakville Centre Sylvain French Oak Family Reserve South | 2014 | $215.00 | No market data found | No exact-vintage market data found after web search / Wine-Searcher-visible snippets / Benchmark / WineBid / K&L / Vivino / CellarTracker / Del Dotto public pages | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | Likely Del Dotto direct/club/cave-only barrel-specific bottling; exact-vintage comp not verified. |
| Oakville 9 Oaks French Oak South | 2014 | $215.00 | No market data found | No exact-vintage market data found after web search / Wine-Searcher-visible snippets / Benchmark / WineBid / K&L / Vivino / CellarTracker / Del Dotto public pages | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | Likely Del Dotto direct/club/cave-only barrel-specific bottling; exact-vintage comp not verified. |
| Oakville Darnajou EAST French Oak Family Reserve | 2020 | $215.00 | No market data found | No exact-vintage market data found after web search / Wine-Searcher-visible snippets / Benchmark / WineBid / K&L / Vivino / CellarTracker / Del Dotto public pages | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | Likely Del Dotto direct/club/cave-only barrel-specific bottling; exact-vintage comp not verified. |
| St. Helena Mountain Vicard French Oak Family Reserve Block 2 | 2016 | $215.00 | $179.95 | Vintage Wines SD, 2016 Del Dotto Family Reserve Vicard FO Cabernet | No critic score found | Fair | Close exact vintage and Vicard FO St. Helena Family Reserve comp, retail price below Trevor's $215. |
| St. Helena Mountain MGX MT+ French Oak Family Reserve Block 2 | 2015 | $215.00 | No market data found | No exact-vintage market data found after web search / Wine-Searcher-visible snippets / Benchmark / WineBid / K&L / Vivino / CellarTracker / Del Dotto public pages | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | Likely Del Dotto direct/club/cave-only barrel-specific bottling; exact-vintage comp not verified. |
| Oakville U-Stave American Oak North | 2013 | $200.00 | No market data found | No exact-vintage market data found after web search / Wine-Searcher-visible snippets / Benchmark / WineBid / K&L / Vivino / CellarTracker / Del Dotto public pages | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | Likely Del Dotto direct/club/cave-only barrel-specific bottling; exact-vintage comp not verified. |
| St. Helena Mountain Darnajou French Oak Vitali & Majka Reserve Block 2 | 2018 | $200.00 | No market data found | No exact-vintage market data found after web search / Wine-Searcher-visible snippets / Benchmark / WineBid / K&L / Vivino / CellarTracker / Del Dotto public pages | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | Likely Del Dotto direct/club/cave-only barrel-specific bottling; exact-vintage comp not verified. |
| Del Dotto THE BEAST | 2014 | $350.00 | $395.00 to $799.99 | The Odd Wine Company 2014 listing $395 sold out; CaskCartel 2014 listing $799.99; Wine-Searcher cited average approx $348 to $350 | Del Dotto producer page says The Beast has received multiple 100-point ratings, vintage-specific critic score not verified; Vivino aggregate 4.8 all vintages | Good Deal | Trevor's $350 is at or below every secondary/retail comp found. Strongest positive comp in the set. |
| St. Helena Mountain Jupille French Oak Block 1 | 2014 | $215.00 | $171.00 | Benchmark Wine Group, 2014 Del Dotto Cabernet Sauvignon Family Reserve St. Helena Mountain | CT96 on Benchmark St. Helena Mountain 2014 listing | Fair | No Jupille exact price; same-vintage St. Helena Family Reserve secondary comp is lower. |
| Rutherford Estate 9 Oaks French Oak 24 Months | 2012 | $215.00 | No market data found | No exact-vintage market data found after web search / Wine-Searcher-visible snippets / Benchmark / WineBid / K&L / Vivino / CellarTracker / Del Dotto public pages | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | Likely Del Dotto direct/club/cave-only barrel-specific bottling; exact-vintage comp not verified. |
| Rutherford Estate MGX Alain Fouquet French Oak Family Reserve | 2013 | $215.00 | No market data found | No exact-vintage market data found after web search / Wine-Searcher-visible snippets / Benchmark / WineBid / K&L / Vivino / CellarTracker / Del Dotto public pages | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | Likely Del Dotto direct/club/cave-only barrel-specific bottling; exact-vintage comp not verified. |
| St. Helena Mountain Centre Saury French Oak B1 Cabernet Sauvignon | 2014 | $215.00 | $171.00 | Benchmark Wine Group, 2014 Del Dotto Cabernet Sauvignon Family Reserve St. Helena Mountain | CT96 on Benchmark St. Helena Mountain 2014 listing | Fair | No Centre Saury exact price; same-vintage St. Helena Family Reserve secondary comp is lower. |
| Oakville Vicard French Oak North | 2014 | $215.00 | No market data found | No exact-vintage market data found after web search / Wine-Searcher-visible snippets / Benchmark / WineBid / K&L / Vivino / CellarTracker / Del Dotto public pages | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | Likely Del Dotto direct/club/cave-only barrel-specific bottling; exact-vintage comp not verified. |
| Giovanni's Tuscan Reserve | 2014 | $150.00 | No exact 2014 price found | K&L had 2013 Giovanni's Tuscan Reserve page; Del Dotto has 2024 product page; no 2014 price found | Vivino aggregate 4.6 all vintages, not a critic score | No Market Comp Available | No exact 2014 market comp found. |
| St. Helena Mountain MGX Alain Fouquet Block 3 | 2013 | $215.00 | No market data found | No exact-vintage market data found after web search / Wine-Searcher-visible snippets / Benchmark / WineBid / K&L / Vivino / CellarTracker / Del Dotto public pages | No critic score found | No Market Comp Available | Likely Del Dotto direct/club/cave-only barrel-specific bottling; exact-vintage comp not verified. |